Higher education has played a pivotal role in shaping individuals and advancing society since its beginnings. Dating back to 1636, the history of higher education in the United States has seen constant evolution to meet changing societal needs, advancements in learning methods, and expanding knowledge landscapes. Recent decades have witnessed a global push to enhance access to higher education, with governments and institutions adopting policies to promote inclusivity and boost enrollment rates. Online and distance learning have further facilitated remote degree pursuit, widening educational opportunities. In the conventional understanding of career advancement, securing a college degree was widely regarded as the pathway to landing a job relevant to that degree.
However, in recent years, a noticeable trend has emerged—college enrollments are decreasing, while simultaneously, there’s a surge in demand for skills-based hiring. This shift marks a significant departure from the conventional route to employment and underscores a fundamental change in how individuals and employers perceive qualifications and competencies. As new graduates navigate the evolving job market, and incoming freshmen gear up for their academic journeys, the landscape of higher education and career preparation continues to transform, reflecting broader societal and economic shifts.
The decline in college enrollment
Employees holding Bachelor’s degrees earn an annual income that is 75 percent higher and accumulate approximately $1.2 million more over their lifetime than individuals with only a high school diploma. However, one of the most striking trends in higher education has been the decline in college enrollments. Over the last ten years, there has been a drop in total college enrollment by nearly 1.5 million students, representing approximately a 7.4 percent decrease.
There are several factors contributing to this trend:
Economic pressures. From 1980 to 2023, the average cost of college tuition, fees, and room and board rose by 155 percent—making it increasingly unaffordable for many individuals. As student debt reaches unprecedented levels, prospective students are questioning the return on investment of a traditional four-year degree. In fact, 56 percent of Americans believe the cost of earning a four-year degree outweighs the value.
Alternative paths to success. The increase in alternative education and training options, such as online courses, boot camps, certificate programs, internships, and vocational programs, has provided learners with more accessible and often more targeted avenues to gain relevant skills for the labor market.
Changing perceptions. There’s a growing recognition that a college degree doesn’t guarantee employment or success in the workforce. Around 50 percent of individuals who graduate from college find themselves in occupations where the skills from their degrees are not required. Many workers are opting to explore alternative routes that offer more immediate and tangible returns in terms of career advancement and earning potential.
The rise of skills-based hiring
Concurrent with the decline in college enrollments, there has been a notable shift in hiring practices among employers. Increasingly, companies are prioritizing skills over formal degrees when evaluating candidates for roles with 73 percent of employers using skills-based hiring in 2023, marking an increase from 56 percent in 2022.
This trend can be attributed to several factors:
Demand for specialized skills. In today’s rapidly evolving employment market, employers are seeking candidates with specific, job-relevant skills rather than broad academic knowledge. This is particularly evident in industries such as technology, where skills in areas like coding, data analysis, and digital marketing are in high demand.
Focus on performance and potential. Employers are recognizing that skills and competencies are better indicators of an individual’s ability to perform a job effectively than the pedigree of their alma mater. Ten soft skills have been identified as the greatest priority and most in-demand in the United States. By prioritizing skills-based hiring, companies can identify candidates with the right capabilities to drive innovation and productivity within their organizations.
Diversity and inclusion. Unconscious biases can inadvertently influence the hiring process when evaluating a candidate’s resume, which may include cues such as elite educational backgrounds, prestige, race, or generational wealth. However, none of these factors necessarily guarantee career success. Prioritizing skills-based hiring allows employers to focus on what truly counts. Employers can create more diverse and inclusive workforces that draw talent from various sources.
The implications for education and employment
The shift toward skills-based hiring has significant implications for both education and employment:
Education reimagined. As the demand for skills-based hiring continues to grow, educational institutions will need to adapt their curricula to better align with the needs of the labor market. This may involve integrating more practical, hands-on learning experiences and providing opportunities for students to develop industry-relevant skills alongside academic knowledge.
Lifelong learning. Learning doesn’t end with graduation in a skills-based environment. Continuous upskilling and reskilling will become essential for staying competitive. Employers may increasingly look for candidates who commit to lifelong learning and professional development. On the flip side, 79 percent of CEOs worldwide are worried about the availability of key skills. Employers that offer training benefit from hiring retention rates (94 percent of employees expressed that having development opportunities would motivate them to stay in their current position) along with increased profits (21 percent) and worker productivity (17 percent).
Redefining success. The traditional notion of success defined by a college degree is evolving. Individuals are recognizing that there are multiple pathways to a fulfilling and successful career and success can be measured by one’s ability to acquire and apply relevant skills in the workplace.
Conclusion
The decline in college enrollments and the rise of skills-based hiring represent a seismic shift in how people prepare for and pursue careers. While a college degree may still hold value in certain fields, the emphasis on skills signals a broader reevaluation of what constitutes qualifications and success in the modern workforce. As both education and employment paradigms continue to evolve, embracing a skills-first approach empowers workers to thrive in an increasingly dynamic and competitive labor market and offers a way for employers to expand their talent pools.
Related: Expanding Talent Pools Through Skills-Based, Neurodivergent, and Retiree Hiring
Contact Worklink Group to unlock the full potential of your talent pool through skills-based hiring.
